"Cradle and All" commentary
Apr. 14th, 2025 06:37 pmHi everyone! Thank you for both reading the fic and caring enough to come and read my commentary! I've never done a fic commentary before, but with this fic, it turns out I have lots of thoughts about wish babies, taking about nine months to write said fic, and also writing fic for a show I have not watched. [As a note, I wrote this between Feb. 12 and March 2nd, so it doesn't involve anything to do with S8b or my more recent, ongoing watch-through.]
First, as of typing this, I've seen ... two or three episodes of 9-1-1. The season 8 Halloween episode got posted on twitter and so I watched it, then I watched the next... 2? Live. SO that was fun (Eddie Risky Business dancing and BuckTommy breakup live was an incredible way to start watching officially/unofficially). But for the majority of writing this fic, I was basing a lot of things off of what I learned from my friends in the fandom, who put together a powerpoint about the show/buddie specifically. Also I've read frankly more than my fair share of fic, and watched tons of edits.
WISH BABIES! As I said in the author's note, I started writing this fic because in a discord, we were talking about wish baby fics, and how they aren't terribly widespread, or popular. But those of us who've read them and written them love them, and we want more wish baby fics in the world. We were also talking about buddie/Bi!Buck in a different channel, so we all agreed that Buck would absolutely be someone who would get an accidental wish baby. And thus, this fic was spawned.
The main thing about wish babies is that "babies are born because people wish them out of the sky." When I first encountered the idea/what I believe is the original wish baby fic, I was thinking of it in a way that means every baby is wanted, and everyone who wants a baby enough can wish one into existence. Essentially doing away with people having children who don't want them and infertility in one fell swoop. But in thinking about how wish babies exist within a canon that includes that not-quite-happy accidental baby that is Chris, and the whole Eddie and Shannon of it all, I got to think about how wishing could be accidentally mis-directed toward a baby. Similar to how people sometimes think a baby will fix a relationship and that's practically never the right move, but with more wiggle room. Of course, wish baby universes are similar to the omegaverse in that there is no one set of rules, so if you prefer a wish baby universe in which many babies are born the quote-unquote “usual” way, but there are also babies wished out of the sky, that works too. But that's not the wish baby universe of this fic.
Okay, with that out of the way, let's get on to the contents of the fic!
( Chapter by chapter commentary under here! )